Not very long ago I watched a fascinating documentary by Stephen Fry on manic depression. I was reminded about the rollercoaster mood swings of people in that movie as I watched the markets on Budget Day. Panel after panel of pundits debated why the budget had not delivered the flavourful cocktail they thought the people had been thirsting for. Although the salaried class, senior citizens and women wage-earners benefited from some tax trimming, the consensus was that this was not a go-for-it reform budget.
Wait a minute – so the speculators and the day-traders and the swashbucklers were caught with their shorts down. Public memory is very short. People have forgotten that the Bombay Sensex rocketed 52.57 % between January 1 and June 30 this year. In comparison, the Dow Jones Industrial Average has actually fallen from 9034 on January 1 to 8447 on June 30. And
So the journey of the Sensex this year can only be described as manic. Did the fundamentals merit this kind of irrational rise – or Monday’s depressive fall?
Nobody really knows how badly the aam admi, the common Indian, has been hit – 92% of the workforce is in the “informal” or unorganised sector, so unemployment figures are poor estimates. Anecdotally, it is clear that millions of people have lost their jobs in the gems and jewellery, textile, leather and small and medium enterprise sectors.
Another indicator is the massive slowdown in industrial production, to 2.4% in 2008/09 from 8.5% a year earlier. Exports and imports both declined sharply; the trade deficit ballooned 35% to $119 billion, and foreign exchange reserves declined by nearly 17% to $262 billion at end-May.
Mukherjee listed several steps to aid exporters. But internal investment has plunged -- growth in fixed capital formation declined from 12.9 % in 2007-08 to 8.2% in 2008/09. External commercial borrowings dried up, capital accretion through the stock markets slowed to a trickle, and banks became much more reluctant to lend.
How many people exactly are out of work in
Unemployment among farm workers rose to 15.3% in 2004/05. Growth in real wages of farm workers slowed down in the 2000s as agricultural growth decelerated.
The Planning Commission estimated in 2007 that the number of unemployed totalled 36.7 million in 2006/07. It predicted optimistically that this would fall to 23.3 million in 2011/12. But that was before the global crisis. “This growing integration of the Indian economy with the rest of the world has brought new opportunities and also new challenges. It has made the task of sustaining high growth more complex,” Pranab Mukherjee said, almost ruefully.
Instead of bold changes in direction, the finance minister announced he would pump even more money -- Rs 39,100 crores ($8.3 billion) or a 144% increase over 2008/09 -- into the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme, which created jobs for 44.7 million people last year. This is going to be even more critical given that growth in the agriculture sector slumped to 1.6% in 2008/09 from 4.9% a year earlier.
So there may not have been breathtaking reforms, but there was plenty of stimulation, totalling Rs 186,000 crore ($39.6 billion) in 2008/09, and that pushed up the fiscal deficit to 6.2 % of GDP. That will rise further to 6.8% of GDP in 2009/10 – the finance minister proudly remarked that government expenditure will exceed 10.2 trillion rupees ($217 billion) this fiscal year, a leap of 36% over last year. That is going to be fuelled by a 50% rise in government borrowing. After his speech, Mukherjee told a TV interviewer that this was not too alarming because the
Actually, as the RBI noted in its April policy statement, the combined Central and State fiscal deficits, plus special securities issued by the centre outside the market borrowing programme, will take the nation’s fiscal deficit to 10.8% of GDP. No wonder the ratings agencies are getting more and more twitchy by the day, and that Mukherjee said the challenge of recovery has to be shouldered jointly by the centre and the states.
“The deficit is too high and
Mukherjee said net market borrowings are likely to hit Rs 400,000 crores in 2009/10. In the first half of this fiscal year alone, the RBI has committed itself to purchase government securities under open market operations to the tune of Rs 80,000 crores. In the absence of a corporate-bond market, this means that “real interest rates” will be unrealistically high for companies who are getting muscled out of the debt markets by the government-central bank behemoth.
Mukherjee pledged to return to the “path of fiscal consolidation at the earliest”. But his ministry’s Economic Survey, published last week, said it might be time to go for an “FRBM-2” of zero fiscal deficits.
The stimulation cannot be denied – the Sixth Pay Commission is estimated to have pumped close to an additional Rs 117,000 crores ($25 billion) into government employees’ wallets since last October, and may have added 1.1 percentage points to GDP.
The OECD predicted last month that
But the past year has laid to rest the myth that
(This piece appeared in the Khaleej Times on July 10, 2009)
No comments:
Post a Comment